Stakes high in bridge battle
By Carol Sanders
Winnipeg Free Press
Sunday, Dec 15, 2002

A developer says an environmental group's objection to the proposed construction of a bridge over the Seine River could halt a 760-home subdivision in south Winnipeg.

"Many builders, trades and suppliers and all of their employees and their families will be very seriously affected," said Alan Borger, president of Ladco Co. Ladco and the province are partners in Grandin Park Developments Ltd., which had planned to begin construction of Phase 2 of Royalwood next spring.

The company wants to build a bridge over the Seine River at Southglen Boulevard near St. Anne's Road.

A group called Save Our Seine is fighting the bridge proposal, saying it cuts through pristine forest area the group is eyeing for the 80-acre Bois des Esprits, a park system of canoe and hiking trails from south Winnipeg to downtown.

"People try to belittle the impact of the bridge," said Dave Danyluk, co-ordinator for Save Our Seine Environment Inc. "Its environmental impact is a big concern."

The planned river park takes its name from the spirits of the first nations people, Metis and settlers who called the forest home. It is an area steeped in history. Borger says he respects the group, but thinks its plan to attract 120,000 people a year by building a cafe, a canoe launch, paved pathways and parking lots along the river is potentially more dangerous to the environment along the river than the bridge.

"The SOS group has done a commendable job enhancing the Seine River environment and has shown tremendous dedication to their cause," said Borger.

"But on this issue, they appear to be out in left field."

The two sides will square off Tuesday at the Riel community committee meeting, during which area city councillors will review the plans for the housing development and hear the case for and against the bridge.
SOS says it isn't against the development --just the bridge planned at Southglen, where there is "A-quality" unspoiled forest. The developer has owned the land at Southglen west of the Seine since the 1980s, when it was directed by the city to obtain it for access to the planned development, which was postponed until the late 1990s.

SOS says an alternative access site at Warde Avenue would cut through a less valuable tract of forest. Danyluk said one traffic study showed a Warde Avenue bridge would easily handle all the traffic in and out of the development. But Borger said that's not a safe or practical option. Emergency vehicles need to have more than one access road to a development, he said, so there will eventually have to be bridges at both Southglen and Warde.

Grandin Park Development wants to build the Southglen bridge next winter. Borger said it will allow three metres of clearance to accommodate canoeists and hikers below, and the company is footing the bill.

He said Royalwood's economic impact is huge, with $174 million in construction being spent in Phase 2 and the city raking in an estimated $4.1 million a year in property taxes.

The development is good for the city and the environment, said Borger.

"Our proposal is extremely ecologically sensitive."

Ecologists were consulted on how to "naturalize" man-made lakes in the area and develop a wetlands habitat, he said. Phase 2 of Royalwood will boast a buffer of native grasses to promote wildlife in the area and help filter phosphates and nitrates before they enter the river, Borger said.
SOS's plan to develop tourism along the river could have a bigger negative impact on the environment than the Southglen bridge, he said, adding the bridge would affect a very small part of the Bois des Esprits.

"All but 2.5 acres will be preserved," he said. SOS says developing that section of the forest will be "devastating and unnecessary."

On Monday, SOS has a meeting with the province, which has a 38 per cent stake in the Royalwood project. Danyluk said SOS will ask the province to step in and help buy the land to save the forest.
The city already owns about 44 per cent of the riverbank land along the Seine and it will cost more than $2 million to acquire another 40 acres for the Bois des Esprits.

The city has committed $1 million to the project and challenged the community to raise another $600,000, which the city will match to purchase the other 40 acres. As of last week, SOS had raised $67,000.

"The city knows this parcel of land is important and unique," said Danyluk. "We'd like to see some support from the province. They've got a stake in this land."

The province partnered with Ladco to develop the land inside the Perimeter Highway in an attempt to prevent urban sprawl in a city that's running out of acreage to develop.

Developers have been heading outside the Perimeter for available sites, taking valuable municipal taxes with them. In May, the province said it planned to work with the private sector to develop more provincial land in the city.

The Manitoba government and Ladco pooled 485 acres of land to create the Royalwood subdivision. Phase 1 of that project is almost complete, and the remaining two phases were expected to go ahead this year. All three phases of Royalwood are together expected to generate $7.6 million in annual property taxes when they are completed.


Back to In the Media


Back to Main