Seine River faceoff tonight
By Carol Sanders
Winnipeg Free Press
Tuesday, Dec 17, 2002

The gloves are off in a fight to save one of the last stands of pristine forest along the Seine River being eyed for a bridge to a new housing development.

The group called Save Our Seine River Environment Inc. (SOS) has accused Grandin Developments Inc. of launching a "smear campaign" against the non-profit group that's trying to save the forest and stop a proposed bridge at Southglen Boulevard. "It's a tragedy because a smear campaign has derailed our efforts of fund-raising," said Jules Legal, spokesman for SOS.

His group has been trying to raise money to help the city buy the affected land from the developer, a joint venture involving Ladco Company Ltd. and the province. It plans to build 760 homes in Phase 2 of Royalwood. Tonight, the two sides will come face to face at a Riel Community Committee public meeting to discuss the development and bridge proposal.

Ladco president Alan Borger has said if the city doesn't approve the company's planned bridge at Southglen, the development will be put on hold. SOS has said it doesn't oppose the development, just the bridge. Its construction will require the river to be rechannelled, permanently changing the nature of the Grade-A forest in the area and harming the river ecosystem, said Legal.

Borger is using a 2001 concept plan prepared for SOS and Riel Development Corp. to attack the environmental group, said Legal. The Gaboury Prefontaine Perry architects' Bois des Esprits Park Plan talks about making the river more accessible and the possible economic spin-offs.

A copy of the plan was presented to the company for comment in March 2001, but Grandin Developments didn't respond --until last month, said Legal. It sent letters to people in the area warning that the SOS/Riel plan calls for asphalt walkways, an inn and facilities to attract 120,000 visitors to the area. Legal said the proposal was more of a discussion paper or concept plan and that SOS is not in favour of developing the area's tourism potential. It only wants to save the trees.

"At no time did we ever suggest any kind of commercial development within the forest," said Jules Legal. "These commercial spin-offs have nothing to do with forest."

Borger accused the group of trying to distance itself from the report.

"When exactly did they abandon this report?" he asked. "I will stick by my comments, especially in light of the fact that its executive summary still appears on their (SOS's) Web site."

Legal said Borger's contention earlier that SOS's park plan may be worse than the traffic bridge is outrageous. The developer has applied to the Department of Fisheries and Oceans to "re-channel" the river to accommodate the bridge. Borger admitted bridge construction will require the rechannelling of the Seine because the riverbank at Southglen is failing and its close proximity to St. Anne's Road.

The city has offered $1 million to buy the land owned by the developer and promised to match any funds raised by SOS up to $600,000 to purchase the land. So far the group has raised less than $70,000.


Back to In the Media


Back to Main